BAMS

10th Grade Public Speaking & Debate Practice: Questions, Answers and Tips

Looking for 10th grade public speaking & debate practice? Below are worked examples, the mistakes students make most, and practice questions with an answer key.

3 min read

In this article

Looking for 10th grade public speaking & debate practice? Below are worked examples, the mistakes students make most, and practice questions with an answer key.

Every example below comes from BAMS Academy's Public Speaking & Debate practice, the same questions students answer on the site.

Public Speaking & Debate in 10th grade, skill by skill

Advanced argumentation and formal debate skills. BAMS Academy breaks the unit into the skills below. Each comes with one of its practice questions.

Identify claim, warrant, backing, and qualifier, and locate the burden of proof

In formal argumentation, In policy debate, which side carries the burden of proof? (Choices: The affirmative, because it proposes a change from the status quo; The negative, because it must defend the current system; Both sides equally at all times; Whichever side speaks second.)

Answer: The affirmative, because it proposes a change from the status quo. Whoever proposes the change must justify it. The negative need only show the case has not been made.

Use cross-examination effectively and name advanced fallacies

Identify what is happening: the purpose of cross-examination (Choices: To summarize the debate so far for the judge; To confuse the opponent with rapid questions; To deliver additional arguments of your own; To secure admissions you will use in your next speech.)

Answer: To secure admissions you will use in your next speech. Cross-x is for extraction. Arguments belong in speeches, where the opponent cannot interrupt.

Formal debate names its failure modes precisely. "A celebrated novelist says this tax plan will work, so it will." (Choices: Post hoc; Ad hominem; Appeal to inappropriate authority; False dilemma.)

Answer: Appeal to inappropriate authority. Expertise does not transfer across domains. Citing a relevant economist would not be fallacious.

Identify what is happening: "Test scores rose the year after the new principal arrived, so the principal caused the rise." (Choices: Straw man; Circular reasoning; False dilemma; Post hoc ergo propter hoc.)

Answer: Post hoc ergo propter hoc. Sequence is being treated as causation with no mechanism or control offered.

Worked examples

Example 1

Question: Toulmin's model names each moving part of an argument. The strongest way to attack an argument whose evidence is accurate

  1. Challenge the warrant — show the evidence does not support that conclusion
  2. Point out that the opponent spoke too quickly
  3. Present more evidence for your own side and move on
  4. Insist the evidence must be fabricated

How to solve it: When facts are not in dispute, the inference from them is the remaining target.

Answer: Challenge the warrant — show the evidence does not support that conclusion

Example 2

Question: In formal argumentation, what "presumption" means in formal debate

  1. The status quo stands unless the affirmative meets its burden
  2. Both teams presume the resolution is true
  3. The audience decides before the debate begins
  4. The judge presumes the first speaker is correct

How to solve it: Presumption is the default. It is why an affirmative that merely ties has still lost.

Answer: The status quo stands unless the affirmative meets its burden

Try these practice questions

  1. Toulmin's model names each moving part of an argument. The unstated assumption that licenses the move from evidence to claim

    1. The warrant
    2. The rebuttal
    3. The evidence
    4. The qualifier
  2. Toulmin's model names each moving part of an argument. The word or phrase that limits how strongly a claim is asserted

    1. The backing
    2. The warrant
    3. The rebuttal
    4. The qualifier
  3. Toulmin's model names each moving part of an argument. The additional support offered when an opponent challenges the warrant

    1. The evidence
    2. The claim
    3. The backing
    4. The qualifier
Answer key
  1. The warrant — In Toulmin's model the warrant is the hidden bridge. Exposing it is how you attack an argument at its root.
  2. The qualifier — Qualifiers like "in most cases" or "presumably" narrow a claim, which makes it harder to refute.
  3. The backing — Backing defends the warrant itself, which is a different job from providing evidence for the claim.

Keep practicing

The fastest way to build confidence is a few questions at a time, with feedback on each answer. Start with Public Speaking & Debate practice for grade 10, where every question comes with a step-by-step explanation.

More from BAMS Academy:

Share

Ready to practice?